No items found.
2023-03-31

How Investing vs Trading impacts tax

In most cases of buying and selling cryptocurrency as a retail investor, you are participating in investing rather than trading. The two are treated differently for tax purposes.

  • Investing is subject to capital gains tax or income tax, depending on the nature of the transaction.
  • Trading in this case refers to self-employment which is subject to income tax and National Insurance Contributions.

The key difference between investing and trading – along with the different tax treatments, is how losses generated in the crypto-activity can be used.

In their guidance, HMRC have explicitly stated that they would expect it to be exceedingly rare that any crypto-activity constituting buying & selling crypto would be classified as “trading”.

If you are uncertain, speak to a tax advisor as there are always exceptions, including but not limited to, developing tokens and large scale mining.

How is crypto tax calculated in the United States?

You can be liable for both capital gains and income tax depending on the type of cryptocurrency transaction, and your individual circumstances. For example, you might need to pay capital gains on profits from buying and selling cryptocurrency, or pay income tax on interest earned when holding crypto.

All Countries

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
USA flag
Canada
blog
31
 
Mar
 
2023
 - 
10
min read

YFI Tax Guide

Everyone has heard of YFI recently but few are familiar with the tax implications of holding YFI. The DeFi space is so new there are different tax scenarios depending on how and when you acquired your YFI. Here is a brief YFI tax guide to help you with the process.

Key takeaways
This tax guide is regularly updated: Last Update  
CryptoTax Calculator thumbnail

A quick background on YFI

YFI was released in July by Andre Cronje as a governance token for Yearn finance. The supply was capped at 30,000 and was meant to have no value but to help decide the future of the project through community involvement. As a reward for providing liquidity people were airdropped YFI tokens based on how much liquidity they provided. YFI was also tradable on Uniswap so even though it was conceived to have no value holders could sell it and speculators could buy it.

Based on this there are two unique scenarios for how holders could acquire YFI that result in two distinct tax possibilities.

You Bought YFI on Uniswap

If you bought YFI on Uniswap this was likely how the transaction flow could have gone:

  1. You sold 1 ETH and in return got 10 YFI tokens

  2. You held YFI during the price rise and decided to sell some of your stack

  3. You sold 5 YFI for 200 ETH

  4. The price goes even higher and you sell the rest of your stack

  5. You sold the remaining 5 YFI for 300 ETH

Based on this transaction flow there are 3 distinct tax events that potentially occur.

  1. When you bought 10 YFI you also sold 1 ETH, because you disposed of one asset this triggers a capital gain event on the 1 ETH you held.

  2. When you sold the first 5 YFI it triggers another capital gains event, at this point, it would be a capital gain and not a loss where the gain would be the difference in your buy and sell price in AUD (not ETH).

  3. When you sell the remaining YFI it triggers a capital gain event similar to number 2.

You acquired YFI from providing liquidity in the Yearn.finance protocol

Because in this case, you didn’t buy YFI the tax implications are a bit different.

Let’s say the transaction flow went like this:

  1. You were airdropped 3 YFI for providing liquidity, at the time 1 YFI = $40

  2. You sell all 3 of your YFI 2 weeks later for 120 ETH

  3. You move your ETH to a centralized exchange like Binance and exchange the 120 ETH for $70,000 AUD

Again based on the transactions above there are 3 separate tax events that could have occurred:

  1. When you are airdropped the YFI you incur an income tax based on the value at the time of airdropping, in this case, $120

  2. When you sell your 3 YFI for 120 ETH this incurs a capital gains tax event, at the time you sell the 10 ETH is worth $65,000, so the capital gains are $65,000 - $120 = $64,880.

Moving the ETH to another exchange doesn’t incur a tax but exchanging the ETH for AUD does incur another capital gains tax. In this case, because you bought the ETH for $65,000 when you sold the YFI and now it is worth $70,000 the capital gains are $5,000.

So based on this case you owe income tax on the $120 and capital gains on the $69,880.

The key differentiator here is that if you buy YFI you are only subject to capital gains tax but if you gained YFI from providing liquidity you are also subject to income tax.

Wrapping Up

If you were one of the lucky few to buy YFI or even better earn YFI from supplying liquidity it could be one of the most profitable trades of your life. However, the tax office, no matter what country you are in is going to want a healthy bite of that profit. Figuring out exactly what you owe based on how and when you acquired YFI is a legal requirement. Luckily for you, Summ (formerly Crypto Tax Calculator) can automate that process for you.

The information provided on this website is general in nature and is not tax, accounting or legal advice. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on this information, you should consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to your own objectives, financial situation and needs and seek professional advice. Summ (formerly Crypto Tax Calculator) disclaims all and any guarantees, undertakings and warranties, expressed or implied, and is not liable for any loss or damage whatsoever (including human or computer error, negligent or otherwise, or incidental or Consequential Loss or damage) arising out of, or in connection with, any use or reliance on the information or advice in this website. The user must accept sole responsibility associated with the use of the material on this site, irrespective of the purpose for which such use or results are applied. The information in this website is no substitute for specialist advice.

FAQ

No items found.
Table of contents
heading2
heading3

More resources

CryptoTax Calculator thumbnail
Blog
17
 
Oct
 
2025
Big News: Crypto Tax Calculator has rebranded to Summ
Read More
CryptoTax Calculator thumbnail
Blog
26
 
Aug
 
2025
Will Trump Remove Tax On Crypto?

Tax experts discuss whether Donald Trump is likely to issue an executive order to reduce or eliminate capital gains tax from cryptocurrency, and what other policies might benefit investors.

Read More
CryptoTax Calculator thumbnail
Blog
25
 
Jul
 
2025
How The IRS Knows You've Traded Crypto

These are the tactics the IRS uses to collect data, track crypto and match it to your identity. And what to do if you've get audited.

Read More

Try Summ today

Import your transactions and generate a free report preview.